To join or leave this study group, please fill out the form at the bottom of this page.
Dr. Stephen Harris
Dr. Andrea Sangiacomo
Dr. Stephen Harris
Upcoming activities of this group
Past activities of this group
Topic & aim
The parameters of the discipline of Philosophy have been established through its development in European (and then Western) history. And yet it is not the case that cultures outside this historical narrative lack sophisticated philosophical traditions. One of the most pressing questions for the discipline today is whether (and to what extent) it should be more inclusive of these excluded traditions? What would this mean for the enterprise and practice of Philosophy? If principles of exclusion and inclusion are to be applied to the field, on what basis should these be formulated and how can they avoid being offensive? The field engages the politics of knowledge very seriously.
One of the questions that troubles the comparative philosophy agenda is the problem of whether its subject is really philosophy at all, or is it really a branch of cultural studies? When we talk about ‘comparison’ what are our referents and to what extent do we fabricate them as we go along? To sidestep this, there is also talk of ‘global philosophy,’ which seeks synthesis and inclusion rather than differentiation and comparison. The field engages comparative and transnational methodologies.
To what extent is it helpful and progressive to view Philosophy as having a central core of European ideas that are then exported and ‘compared’ with other traditions? Is part of the power of comparative philosophy the potential for disrupting European conventions by re-reading the European canon in the light of extra-European concepts? To what extent might comparative philosophy exclude Europe altogether, focusing instead on comparisons of other regional, cultural traditions. The field engages post-colonialism.
Does the enterprise of comparative philosophy ultimately require the rebuilding of the discipline from the ground up, or can it be accommodated as a subfield?
This working group seeks to consider all of these questions through critical analyses of ‘non-European’ philosophers, texts, and traditions.
Set-up & practicalities
In the first instance, the CGP group aims to meet four times a year for research seminars and special lectures. In addition, the group will hold a reading-group that will aim to meet once per month to consider core texts in this emerging tradition as well as recent publications. We anticipate that other activities will emerge from the interaction and dialogue that should characterise a group of this kind.
OZSW members who belong to this group
|Vintges, Karen||University of Amsterdam|
|De Haas, Frans||Leiden University|
|Leezenberg, Michiel||University of Amsterdam|
|Sangiacomo, Andrea||University of Groningen|
|Van Eyghen, Hans||Free University Amsterdam|
|Prange, Martine||Tilburg University|
|Jansen, Yolande||University of Amsterdam|
|Coetzee, Azille||Free University Amsterdam|
|Delissen, Noortje||Utrecht University|
|Kotzeva, Anna||Utrecht University|
|Goto-Jones, Chris||Leiden University|
|Fu, Cissie||Leiden University|
|Robbiano, Chiara||Utrecht University|
|Boele van Hensbroek, Pieter||University of Groningen|
|Thabet, Emad||Free University Amsterdam|
|van der Zweerde, Evert||Radboud University Nijmegen|
|Harris, Stephen||Leiden University|
|Mertens, Mayli||Twente University|
|Meyns, Chris||Utrecht University|
|Trappes, Rose||Radboud University Nijmegen|
|Eilenberger, Hans-Georg||Radboud University Nijmegen|
|Berenpas, Martine||Leiden University|
|Hupkes, Sanne||University of Groningen|
|Yu, Jing||Leiden University|
|Yue, Shenghao||Leiden University|
|den Boer, Lucas||University of Groningen|
|Doeland, Lisa||Radboud University Nijmegen|
Other people who belong to this group
Floris Velema, Glen Newey, Andre van der Braak, Adam Buben, Daniel Cuneo, Agnieszka Rostalska, Diana Martin, Sina Talachian, Henk Blezer, Martin Kovan, Giuseppe Menditto, Renate Schepen, Tania Kochetkova, Ady van den Stock, Alice Simionato, Noortje Delissen