
Truthmaker semantics is a new approach to meaning and content, introduced by Kit Fine based on older ideas going back to Bas van Fraassen (1969) and to situation semantics (Fine 2017). Possible-worlds semantics asks in which circumstances a sentence is true. Truthmaker semantics asks a different question: what is it that makes the sentence true? The answer is given in terms of states, that is, parts of reality that verify or falsify a sentence. The state of this ball’s being red verifies “the ball is red”. The larger state of the ball’s being red and the cup’s being empty does not, since half of it has nothing to do with the colour of the ball. Verification in truthmaker semantics is exact: a verifier has to be wholly relevant to what it verifies, no more and no less. The whole framework is built on this one requirement.
The pay-off is a far more fine-grained notion of content than possible-worlds semantics can offer. On the standard account, the content of a sentence is the set of worlds at which it is true, so logically equivalent sentences always have the same content. But “the ball is red” and “the ball is red and the cup is either empty or not” are not made true by the same things, they do not explain the same things, and they are not about the same things, even though they are true in exactly the same worlds. This phenomenon is known as hyperintensionality, and it turns up all over contemporary philosophy: in metaphysical explanation and grounding (Fine 2012a), in reasoning about counterfactual situations (Fine 2012b), and in the logic of permission (Fine 2014). Truthmaker semantics takes these cases in its stride, because it builds the relevant distinctions into the notion of content from the start.
The formal machinery is modest (a partial order of states closed under fusion, together with recursive clauses assigning verifiers and falsifiers to complex sentences), but it has turned out to be remarkably productive. Truthmaker semantics has yielded well-behaved semantics for relevant logic and other non-classical systems (Jago 2020), workable theories of subject matter and partial content, new analyses of ground, essence and counterfactuals, and, over the past few years, a fast-growing body of work in linguistics on plurality, distributivity and anaphora (Champollion 2025). For students the combination is an attractive one: the technical entry costs are low, the philosophical stakes are high, and a great deal of the basic work has still to be done.
Until now, the only way into the field has been a scattered collection of research papers, each with its own notation and its own assumptions about what the reader already knows. That is about to change. Kit Fine and Mark Jago are currently completing the first textbook on truthmaker semantics (Fine and Jago, forthcoming), and this winter school works through selected chapters of the manuscript together with Mark Jago, one of its authors. Each lecture covers one to two chapters, which participants read in advance, and the tutorials are given over to the exercises that accompany them. Participants get a systematic route into a framework that is otherwise hard to enter, they get to argue about it with one of the people shaping it, and, since the book is still in draft, they get a say in how the next generation of students will learn it.
In this 2.5 day winter school, students will:
| Primary target group | RMA and PhD students (1st / 2nd year) |
| If places available also open to | Postdocs and faculty |
| Type of activity | 3 day winter school |
| Certificate credit points | 3 ECTS |
| Organizer | Dr. Johannes Korbmacher, Utrecht University. |
| Location | |
| Date | January 11, 2027 @ 08:00 |
| Venue | Utrecht University |
Program (tentative):
Day 1 (11/01/2027):
Day 2 (12/01/2027):
Ground, subject matter and partial content
Counterfactuals and deontic logic
Day 3 (13/01/2027):
Relevant logic and natural language semantics
Lecturers: Mark Jago, Johannes Korbmacher
Keynote speakers: Mark Jago
Costs:
How to register:
The OZSW registration and cancellation policy applies to this activity (to be found here).
| Name | Dr. Johannes Korbmacher, Utrecht University. |